In April 2026, a Charlotte County presentation on the Don Pedro and Knight Island beach renourishment showed a proposed assessment of $1,903.69 per residential unit per year. The rate in the last cycle had been $239.54. By the county's first budget hearing on September 14, 2026, the same line read $519.80. Over those five months, the project stayed the same and the federal, state and county money behind it grew.
A buyer comparing a home on the islands off Placida with one on the mainland side of the causeway usually starts with the listing price. On Knight Island, Don Pedro and Little Gasparilla, a second set of numbers comes with the address. A ferry operator, a county budget and a family-owned marina at the foot of the Boca Grande Causeway set those numbers, and all three are decided off the island. In 2026 the assessment was reset three times and the marina's sale status changed. The purchase price is the part an island buyer controls most. The yearly cost of getting to the house and keeping its beach depends on others.
Five months, three numbers for the same beach
Charlotte County's April 7, 2026 presentation put the Don Pedro–Knight Island renourishment project at $25,702,246 before any state or federal money. It listed the $1,903.69 proposed residential rate, with a maximum rate of $2,635.26.
By the July 22, 2026 public hearing, FEMA obligations for Don Pedro had reached $8,165,174, up $6.1 million since March 17. The state had awarded $799,875, and another $7,011,120 in state funding was still pending. The proposed residential rate fell to $1,326.53, and the maximum rate was reset at $2,466.43. The county's project page says commissioners voted that day to keep going with the funding strategy while looking at more county contributions.
Those contributions showed up in September. The September 14 first budget hearing table lists the residential rate at $519.80 across 1,215 units, with the $2,466.43 maximum unchanged. Materials for the September 28 final budget hearing add $546,181 from the county's general fund and $182,060 from tourism funds for beach renourishment, for a total of $728,241. The county's July hearing notice said it intended to put the annual assessment on the November 2026 tax bill.
| Rate as listed | Residential rate per unit, per year | Maximum rate |
|---|---|---|
| Cycle 1 rate, prior cycle | $239.54 | n/a |
| April 7 | $1,903.69 | $2,635.26 |
| July 22 | $1,326.53 | $2,466.43 |
| September 14 | $519.80 | $2,466.43 |
The same September 14 table also puts the Don Pedro–Knight Island figure next to its neighbor up the coast. Manasota Key's residential rate was listed at $259.56, with a maximum of $1,286.43. On the table that fall, then, the bridgeless islands south of Stump Pass carried about twice the per-unit charge of Manasota Key and close to twice its ceiling.
The April presentation describes the maximum as the full rate without federal, state or county contributions, and notes that the proposed rate would come down as more state and federal funding is awarded. On these islands, the yearly figure behind a home depends on grant decisions as much as on the house itself. These figures are general information drawn from county records as of the dates shown. They are not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm what applies to a particular parcel with the appropriate professional.
The sand arrives after New Year
The money and the work are on the same timeline. The county took bids on September 30, and commissioners approved the contract at their October 27, 2026 meeting. The county lists construction from January 1 through April 30, 2027, and says a tentative schedule will be released once the pre-construction meeting is held.
For anyone touring Don Pedro or Knight Island this winter, the timing is practical. Work is forecast to run through the heart of the 2027 season, so a showing in February may be on a beach that is still being rebuilt.
The ferry line is the one fixed number
Palm Island Transit's car ferry links the Cape Haze side to Knight Island. It is the one access cost on these islands that is published as a flat number for the calendar year. The homeowner annual vehicle pass for 2026 is $3,000 per vehicle, good from January 1 through December 31, 2026. The operator's posted rates list a homeowner golf cart pass at $1,700, Flex60 and Flex120 passes at $1,500 and $2,100, and round trips without a pass at $55 for a car, $50 for a golf cart, $40 for a motorcycle and $10 for a walk-on.
Divide the pass by the trip price to see who the pass is for. At $55 a round trip, the $3,000 vehicle pass pays for itself at about the 55th crossing. For a golf cart, $1,700 against $50 a round trip comes to 34 crossings. An owner who spends the whole season on the island and drives to the mainland for groceries, a dinner reservation or a doctor's visit gets there fast. An owner who flies in for a few long weekends may never reach it, and the Flex passes exist for that schedule.
Some owners leave the car on the mainland. The posted rate at the Island Park Lot is $15 a day, $250 a month, $600 for three months, $700 for six months or $800 a year, plus a refundable $50 access-card deposit. The ferry's posted hours run from 6:30 a.m. to 10 p.m. Sunday through Thursday, to 11 p.m. on Friday and to midnight on Saturday. Before an offer, check the current rate sheet with the operator, because the posted page predates this season.
Little Gasparilla's mainland is a marina
Little Gasparilla Island has no ferry for cars and no stores. Groceries are bought on the mainland and carried over by water taxi, and golf carts can be rented on the island. A local visitor guide puts Pirate's Water Taxi at about $15 per person each way, with a $30 minimum. For years, the mainland end of that trip has been Eldred's Marina, at the foot of the Boca Grande Causeway.
The Dixon family opened Eldred's marina, bait shop and boat ramp in 1972 on what YourSun described as a 12-acre property. According to the Boca Beacon, the property was listed in March 2024 at a reported $40 million asking price and was handled by the brokerage Avison Young. On October 1, 2026, the Boca Beacon reported that the brokerage's signs had come down and the property was off the market.
The Little Gasparilla Island Property Owners Association has been clear about why that history matters on the island. Its January 2025 newsletter asked Charlotte County for a convenient mainland barge landing for goods and for service and septic providers, and for public parking and boat-trailer parking. It said "the possibility that Eldred's will not remain a public marina has heightened the need" for the county to fill those gaps. Down Gasparilla Road, Gasparilla Marina's services page, updated in October 2026, said no covered boat lifts and no transient slips were available at the time.
For a Little Gasparilla buyer, the access cost has no annual pass to point to. It depends on parking and dockage at privately owned mainland marinas, and the best known of those spent two and a half years on the market before the signs came down this fall. Our earlier look at Placida's waterfront pricing found that marina land on this shoreline trades on its own scarcity. On Little Gasparilla, that scarcity is part of the cost of the house.
Reading an island listing with all three lines
Put the three together and the bridgeless islands split by how their access is set. Knight Island and Don Pedro have a published ferry pass and a county assessment listed at three different rates between April and September. Little Gasparilla has a water taxi fare and a mainland landing whose future its owners decide. A mainland home in Placida or along the Cape Haze peninsula has none of these lines. When island and mainland homes sit at similar prices, the difference lies in costs the listing never shows.
Did the $519.80 rate appear on November 2026 tax bills?
The county's July hearing notice said it intended to place the assessment on the November 2026 bill. The $519.80 figure comes from the September 14, 2026 first budget hearing table, and owners should check their own bill for the amount actually charged.
When will renourishment work happen on Don Pedro and Knight Island?
The county forecasts construction from January 1 through April 30, 2027, and says a tentative schedule will follow the pre-construction meeting.
Is Eldred's Marina still for sale?
The Boca Beacon reported on October 1, 2026 that the property had been taken off the market.
If you are weighing a home on Knight Island, Don Pedro or Little Gasparilla this season, Melissa Csank would be glad to sit down with you and put the ferry, assessment and marina lines beside the purchase price before you write an offer. Schedule a Private Consultation.